Introduction
This edition presents a rare surviving example of the kind of multimedia production that
arose from one of the new cultural activities that characterised the late eighteenth century
and gave rise to Romanticism—the picturesque and antiquarian tour. It comprises a facsimile of
the manuscript sketch- and scrap-book that Robert Bloomfield made after his 1807 tour of the
Wye, an annotated transcription of the prose tour-journal that he incorporated into his scrap
book, and a collated and annotated text of the poetic versions of the tour that were published
(as The Banks of Wye) in 1811, 1813, and 1823. Also included are reproductions of
the engravings that illustrated the 1811 and 1813 publications, deleted or unadopted passages
from the manuscript of the poem, and a selection of
reviews from journals of the time. The whole represents a visually and
verbally rich response to the fashionable tour of the Wye that the poets Thomas Gray and William Wordsworth, the artists Paul Sandby and J. M. W. Turner, and the picturesque
theorists William Gilpin and Uvedale Price, made popular.
Entering the valley later
than these tourists, Bloomfield took an already well-travelled and much-described route. His
Wye texts reveal the cultural significance the tour had already acquired but also show the way
that tourism redefined existing genres. It put the topographical and Georgic poem in motion:
views were now observed from a boat or carriage rather than from hilltops. It encouraged
appreciation of native, rather than Italian, scenes and antiquities, identifying the tourist
patriotically with British, rather than classical, landscape and history. And it promoted a
tradition of amateur enquiry: Bloomfield's manuscript sketch- and scrap-book is an example of
the newly popular fashion for on-the-spot sketching. Full of self-penned images of views and
ruins, it is a fine example of the visual culture that the English gentry began to produce and
to value, a homemade book to pass around in drawing rooms before turning either to the latest
set of engravings published by Mr Westall or Mr Turner or to the poetic tour —The Banks
of Wye — that Bloomfield himself issued in print. Bloomfield, indeed, hoped to issue
not just the poetic tour but also the 'whole triple-page'd Journal, Drawings, prose, and
rhime'.1 Cost prohibited such a publication at the
time: only now, with this composite edition of poem, prose, scrap- and sketch-book, can we, the
public, see the multimedia response to the Wye that was then accessible only to the intimate
friends among whom the manuscript circulated.
If this edition reveals much about the picturesque tour and the visual and
manuscript culture of the Romantic era, it also tells us much about Bloomfield himself.
Although hardly a household name or canonical author now, he was, when he took his tour of the
Wye valley and the Welsh borders in 1807, already established as the best-selling 'pastoral
poet' of the age—far better known than Wordsworth and Coleridge, whose Lyrical
Ballads his own Farmer's Boy (1800) outsold by twenty to one. Indeed, in
the eyes of contemporaries, it was Bloomfield, rather than the two West Country and Lakeland
poets we now call 'Romantics', who had revived both landscape verse (the dominant poetic genre
in the 1700s) and Rural Tales (the title of his second, 1802, collection) for the new century.
But he had not done so by harvesting the already-poetic landscape of the Wye valley. For
although Bloomfield admired the work of John Dyer, who had imagined the Welsh Marches as
Siluria—a culturally unique zone in which, since Roman times, British history had been rooted
into the landscape2 — it was nevertheless, the flatter area of Suffolk that inspired his poetry.
Suffolk because it was there, in a small village, that Bloomfield had spent his boyhood and
there, in that same small village, that his family still lived. Bloomfield himself, however,
did not: his rural poetry detailed his Suffolk youth from a distance; it was a new kind of
Georgic not just because it spoke of rural work from the perspective of a labourer rather than
a landowner but also because it spoke from the city. Bloomfield's were poems for the new
urbanising Britain because they remembered the country from the position of a villager who had,
as so many thousands did in the early nineteenth century, emigrated to London. And they did so
from a world of sweated labour: Bloomfield's boyhood was an emotion recollected not in
tranquillity but in the workshop; he composed verse in his head whilst labouring for hours a
day as a shoemaker in an East End garret.
If Bloomfield's poetry gives the lie to Wordsworth's fear (expressed in the
Preface to Lyrical Ballads) that mechanical labour corrupts, by its very
repetitiveness, the taste of the labourer, it nevertheless displays many of the same
characteristics as Wordsworth's own verse—a matter not of mutual influence but of similar
responses to times in which an industrialising culture left many people deracinated and
yearning for a half-remembered place of origin—a childhood land in which the power of capital
had not yet disturbed the culture or the consciousness. These similar responses included the
organisation of verse according to the work-rhythms of shepherds and labourers, the penning of
rural tales based on popular ballads and songs, and the addressing of poems to favourite
landscapes. Not surprisingly, Bloomfield was an early supporter of Wordsworth's poetry: he had
read 'Tintern Abbey' by 1802; he was by 1807 a poet steeped in the latest developments in the
loco-descriptive poetry that James Thomson and William Cowper had perfected a few generations
earlier.
Bloomfield took to the hills. When he climbed Box Hill, Surrey, in 1803,
during a solitary walking tour, it was the first time he had been in upland country, having
previously, like most of the labouring classes, been confined to the fields and the shop where
he worked:
Having been harrassd by too much thinking and too many trivial engagements, and an
employment that I shall never like, I determined that I would respire one mouthfull of real
country air if possible and I know at the same time that pollution of smoke reaches ten miles
round the Metropolis. I had heard much of Leithe Hills and of Box Hill in the neighbourhood of
Dorking. . . . Remember that I am no Welshman, therefore to me these Hills are Cader Idris's
and Snowdens.— (letter 106 of The Letters of Robert Bloomfield: to
George Bloomfield, 17 April 1803)
The tour put Bloomfield in the position of a Romantic for the first time: a solitary walker
travelling as a social, aesthetic and moral antidote to the effects of modern, urban life upon
him. It led to no published writing, only to private correspondence, but it made him all the
more eager to go west in 1807 when a tour of Wales was suggested by his friend Mary Lloyd Baker of Uley in Gloucestershire.
Lloyd Baker, née Sharp, had
written a fan-letter to Bloomfield in 1803. This led to a correspondence and to Bloomfield's
warm reception in Lloyd Baker's extended family-circle of sisters, aunts and uncles, based near
London and in Northamptonshire. The Sharps were radical Whig gentry (Granville Sharp, the anti-slavery and anti-cruelty
campaigner, was Lloyd Baker's uncle) who neither wished to interfere in his publications nor
make him recite verses in public. They had no designs upon him, though he remained conscious of
their difference in class, power and education and knew that he could never reciprocate their
invitations to their houses. But Bloomfield enjoyed their attention and readily made his way in
August 1807 to Uley, to take the tour in the company of
Lloyd Baker, her husband the local landowner,
and their friends Robert Bransby Cooper and his
son and daughter (relatives of the radical surgeon Astley Cooper). Together, the party then
embarked on an elongated version of the already-popular tourist route: they went by road from
Uley to Ross,
then by boat along the Wye, alighting at Tintern.
This route was already established, featuring in the prose of picturesque
tours, and in numerous watercolours and engravings. Of the former, Bloomfield became familiar
with work of the poet Thomas Gray, who toured the
Wye and Wales in summer 1770, and whose enthusiastic notes about the scenery and antiquities
were published after his death as A Catalogue of the Antiquities, Houses, Parks,
Plantations, Scenes, and Situations, in England and Wales (1773). He also refers to the
aesthetic discussions of William Gilpin as
revealed in the seminal work of the picturesque, Observations on the River Wye and
several parts of South Wales, etc. relative chiefly to Picturesque Beauty; made in the summer
of the year 1770 (1782). Gilpin's book was illustrated with plates based on Gilpin's
sketches, etched by his nephew William Sawrey Gilpin using the aquatint process. Sketching as
they went, Bloomfield and his companions continued a fashion for sketching tours that Gilpin
had helped popularise. Sir Joseph Banks had come
down the river in 1771, bringing the artist Paul
Sandby with him, and aquatints after Sandby's pictures circulated widely. In 1794 Sir
George Beaumont, a keen amateur artist, later to be Wordsworth's friend and patron, went to
Tintern with the painter Thomas Hearne. Hearne's pictures were engraved and published in his
Antiquities of Great-Britain, Illustrated in Views of Monasteries, Castles, and
Churches... (1786-1807). Other artists followed, recognising a growing market for
topographical and historical views: by the time Bloomfield embarked, sites on the Wye such as
Goodrich Castle, Tintern Abbey, and Chepstow Castle had been drawn, engraved and published many times over.3 To service the growing numbers of tourists, a local trade grew up:
the Monmouth printer Charles Heath began to
specialise in guidebooks. In rapid succession he published A Descriptive Account of
Raglan Castle (1792), a Descriptive Account of Tintern Abbey (1793), an
Account of the Scenery of the Wye (1795), The Excursion down the Wye
(1796), and Accounts of … Monmouth (1804). Bloomfield used the Excursion
down the Wye in preparing his own Wye texts and also relied upon the recently-published
work of the antiquarian and traveller William Coxe,
A Historical Tour in Monmouthshire (1801).
It was not only in print that the Wye tourist received assistance. An
infrastructure grew up to service travellers' needs, as Suzanne Matheson describes:
A water journey to Tintern Abbey was less taxing for passengers than land-travel,
although not free entirely from danger or discomfort. Recreational excursions on the Wye were
taking place by the 1740s, instituted by the hospitable Rev. Dr. John Egerton of Ross (later
Bishop of Durham), the so-called 'father of the Wye voyage'. In 1745 Egerton 'caused a pleasure
boat to be built to enable his guests to enjoy excursions by water amid scenery which could not
fail to delight and surprise.'4 The
rental and provisioning of manned boats effectively became one of the earliest organized
tourist industries in the area. William Gilpin
travelled in this manner during the fortnight-long 1770 tour that resulted in his influential
Observations on the River Wye. Thomas
Gray ranked his descent of the Wye from Ross
to Chepstow as the 'very principal light, and capital
feature of my journey.'5 By the end of the century, tourist directories advise that these boats,
'lightly constructed, which are used with or without sail, and navigated by three men' were
kept in 'constant readiness' for tourists at Ross-on-Wye.6 In 1796 the charge for a trip from Ross-on-Wye down to
Chepstow at the mouth of the Severn was three guineas,
plus provisioning for the boatmen; from Ross to Monmouth the fee was one and a half guineas. . . . Until the end of the eighteenth
century the boats appear to have been quite simple — 'small, but filled up with no less
convenience than neatness', or 'a good covered boat, well stored with provisions' are typical
descriptions.7 By the late 1830s, however, the vessels had become like 'a small
floating parlour', made commodious with sunshades, cushioned seats, and a table. At Ross 'the
Wye is a good little river, without vices or virtues', as one traveler described.8 After engaging a boat, tourists
would descend past Goodrich Castle situated on
the English or Herefordshire side. Later, in the gorge near Coldwell Rocks, it was common to halt for a climb to
take in the view from Symonds Yat, while the rowers
brought the boat the long way round. Afterwards, the current moving more quickly now, travelers
would pass Raglan Castle, destroyed in the Civil War,
and land at the substantial market town of Monmouth. . . . Roughly ten miles further down-river
from Monmouth is Tintern, where the Wye is tidal and
its character more capricious. Charles Heath warns
in his guide that 'the Boat being obliged to descend with the Tide to Chepstow, two
hours is the utmost time possible that can be allowed the company for visiting the
Abbey'.9 . . . Between Tintern and Chepstow the
river widens and quickens again in its run towards the Severn. The rich farmland of the Lancaut
peninsula, with its little dreaming ruined chapel, contrasts the precipitous rocks and hanging
forests at Wyndcliff. The Upper and Lower Wyndcliff
viewpoints were once part of the grounds of the Piercefield estate, owned by Valentine
Morris. Past Wyndcliff, the sterner limestone cliffs foreshadow the fortifications of
Chepstow Castle.10
Bloomfield's party followed in the wake of earlier travellers, but also added to the Wye
itinerary a further land trip out of the Wye valley into mountainous Wales: Abergavenny, Crickhowell and Brecon, before returning to the
Wye at Hay and proceeding to Hereford, Malvern,
Cheltenham and home.
But it was the boat trip along the river that initially fascinated Bloomfield
and that led him into the spots celebrated by picturesque writers, not least Tintern Abbey.
Bloomfield's response to the famous ruin was a little different from Gilpin's and Wordsworth's:
he neither wished for a mallet to break some of the gables to make the abbey more picturesque
nor averted his gaze from the beggars and ironworks that clustered around. Instead, moved too
deeply to sit and sketch the arches as his companions did, he 'gave vent to my feelings by
singing for their amusement and my own the 104th Psalm'. The 104th Psalm thanks the Lord for creating the earth. In the King James'
version Bloomfield knew, it evokes pastoral valleys such as that in which Tintern stands:
He sendeth the springs into the valleys, which run among the hills.
They give drink to every beast of the field: the wild asses quench their
thirst.
By them shall the fowls of the heaven have their habitation, which sing among
the branches.
He watereth the hills from his chambers: the earth is satisfied with the
fruit of thy works.
He causeth the grass to grow for the cattle, and herb for the service of man:
that he may bring forth food out of the earth.
(Psalm 104:10-14)
Bloomfield declared of his performance 'though no "fretted vault" remains to harmonize the
sound, it soothed me into that state of mind which is most to be desired'. 'Fretted vault' is a
quotation from Gray's 'Elegy Written in a Country Churchyard': 'Where thro' the long-drawn
aisle and fretted vault / The pealing anthem swells the note of praise' (lines 39-40). For
Bloomfield, then, the pastoral valley and ruined church call forth a poetic act of worship,
poetry being the mode which he feels to be profound enough to express his love of nature and
its creator. This act, he knows, is over-determined: he sees the abbey and imagines his
Psalm-singing in relation to Gray's portrait of the country church as a place where the act of
commemoration acquires value. He is self-consciously following in Gray's verse-steps, quietly
claiming poetry as a deeper, more pious, response to Tintern than the picturesque sketches that
tourists were expected to make.
Visiting the Wye as a labourer-poet taken-up by well-meaning patrons, and as a
tourist expected to sing for his tour, Bloomfield found himself in a new and precarious
position. Mostly, he enjoyed it, since, precisely because he had been tied to his trade in a
way gentlemen poets never were (even poor and radical ones like Wordsworth and Coleridge), he
had never before travelled west of London. Nonetheless, his new and, to him, anomalous
position, a visitor rather than rather a Londoner recollecting his native Suffolk, led him to
commence an innovative kind of work—a conventional tour poem (The Banks of Wye
(1811)) that was to accompany a prose guide with accompanying sketches made at picturesque
spots. As such, the project, like Wordsworth's Description of the Scenery of the
Lakes (1811) was a new, hybrid, genre, the tour guidebook as rewritten by the poet to
feature his own verse and illustrations. The effect was to represent the region as a place of
aesthetic value and antiquarian interest: footnotes gave historical information about ruined
castles and Roman forts. Bloomfield hoped to take advantage of his popularity as a
topographical poet and of the Wye's renown as a picturesque location, building on the success
of The Farmer's Boy, which featured many engravings of rural scenes, by feeding
the public's ever-increasing desire for lavishly illustrated books.
Bloomfield began the making of his Wye-book while still basking in the warmth
of the new experience and the attention paid him by the gentlewomen of the party. His letters
show him taking his new roles as artist and tour guide very seriously, seeking sketches and
verse from Mary Lloyd Baker and promising her a
private view of his work:
But of all this I will write more in due time. And you will here probably ask yourself,
what does he mean by due time? Why I mean that when you have fulfilld your
promise, and sent me your Wye Scetches to copy, and the said copying is done. I mean to have
the pleasure of exhibiting to you and them my whole triple-page'd Journal, Drawings, prose, and
rhime.
Since my return I have spent an evening at Fulham, very delightfully. Mr and Mrs Owen,
and a Sweedish Gentleman, the Baron De Gear... The Sweed talkd of the scenery of
the Baltic, Mr O talk'd of the Alps, and of the passage of mount St Gotherd &c, —and I—What
could I talk about?—The Wye, to be sure! (letter 216 of
The Letters of Robert Bloomfield: to Mary Lloyd Baker, 2-5 October 1807)
Once he received the sketches, Bloomfield set about recreating the tour on paper:
I have succeeded beyond the former estimate of my own self approving vanity, and the
proof that I posess that latter article, is my telling you so. They are all done by Candle
light! These long winter evenings are all in my favour, and you may figure to yourself the
solid oak of my old Table bearing on his back half the Castles in Wales, besides my two elbows,
and all the paraphernalia of drawing! Remember that though I am in general pleased with my own
performances I percieve that some of my trees are amazingly like a pile of Cheshire Cheeses.
And one in particular, I was hamper'd with, it seem'd to have a determination to resemble a
large Oil Jar with a handle, but I cut the handle off, and, it became as good a tree as the
rest, aye and as good as some that I have seen at Sadler's Wells. (letter 217 of The Letters of Robert Bloomfield: to T. J. Lloyd Baker, 18 November 1807)
Mildly flirtatious letters of this kind were Bloomfield's way of prolonging a relationship
that was valuable to him: Lloyd Baker's
admiration, and that of her sisters and aunt, gave him confidence without intimidating him (as
the patronage of noblemen tended to do). He flourished in a feminine circle, enjoying being
humorous for their benefit, unbuttoning as he could not to others outside his class, but
knowing, all the same, that his value to these gentlewomen depended upon his amusing them. He
was, nonetheless, careful to show the ladies' powerful husbands that he needed their help too,
consulting Thomas Lloyd Baker and his friend
Robert Bransby Cooper about histories of
Monmouthshire in preparation of the prose section of the book. As a result, he made frequent
use of Coxe's
An Historical Tour in Monmouthshire, adding to both prose journal and verse tour
historical notes that affiliated his work to the antiquarian texts consulted by learned
gentlemen.
Despite Bloomfield's diligent effort, his Wye-book never appeared in the
intended tripartite prose/poetry/picture format. Back in London, away from the Lloyd
Baker/Sharp circle, afflicted by financial difficulties and sinking into depression, he found
work slowing-up. It was not until February 1811, after many months' practice at turning his
rough sketches into finished drawings and much research into local history, that he sent the
Wye-book to his publishers, Vernor and Hood, only to hear that that they were now 'averse to
the costly and fashionable stile of publishing' and would produce only a smaller-scale volume
with no more than four illustrations (letter 256 of The Letters of
Robert Bloomfield: to Mary Lloyd Baker,
16 January-2 February 1811). Their decision may have been an early indication of the financial
difficulties that would bankrupt the firm after Hood's death in 1811. At all events, it made the book they did publish in that year a
far less appealing production, containing only Bloomfield's Georgic verse and a few engravings
after his fellow-tourist Bransby Cooper's
sketches. Nevertheless, The Banks of Wye, now more straightforwardly a poetry
publication, was a substantial work, albeit not one for which the public was looking from a
poet they liked for his tales of village life. Two centuries later, however, we can finally
reconstitute the Wye-book that Bloomfield originally prepared, by accompanying the 1811 poem
with the prose journal (transcribed from the manuscript), exhibiting the sketch- and
scrap-book, restoring deleted passages of the poem from manuscript, and investigating hitherto
unpublished letters.
Reconstituted here, Bloomfield's Wye-book can be seen to have made a
distinctive response to the tour that was, at the same time, a departure in his own
oeuvre—despite its affiliation to the conventional genre of the tourist poem and guidebook. In
part this was, as Tim Burke has noted,11 a matter of Bloomfield's sympathetic understanding of the work of the rural
labourers that he now witnessed, in passing, as a leisured tourist—an understanding that
subverts the unthinking aestheticisation of labour that often characterises the picturesque.
The informal prose journal shows Bloomfield chatting long with a shoemaker friend in Ross;
discussing the price of cider with their Welsh guide; noting that the Welsh girl who served
their meal at Tintern was glad to see them go. Everywhere, he is immediately interested in the
people who work the landscape, regarding them as authorities on it as important as the guide
books, aesthetic treatises and county histories. His viewpoint comprehends not just the viewing
stations built by local landowners such as Valentine
Morris but also the cracks of the floorboards in his inn-chamber, through which he peeps
at the ostlers and maids breakfasting together below. It also sees the burgeoning and smoky
forges, smelters and mills that made the sylvan Wye an important industrial centre. And there
is a passage of social and moral criticism of the Prince of Wales, which Bloomfield's literary
executor Joseph Weston excised from the version of the journal he published in The
Remains of Robert Bloomfield (1824):
The prince was at Cheltenham, and though the
votaries of fashion follow him as gnats do a horse, to sting him, or to be lashd to death, I
found all moralists, and all thinkers, through the whole xxxxx <town> speak of him with a shake of the head, and a humbled, and negative
kind of exultation—I hope the feeling will last as long as truth and
history.
Although Bloomfield was not a political writer, there are acerbic comments about the excess
and hypocrisy of the wealthy in his letters and he maintained radical and reformist sympathies.
These, however, are not apparent in Weston's timorous and conventional version of the journal,
which was posthumously produced and had no authorial sanction (it appeared with spelling and
punctuation regularised and with occasional slang and accompanying sketches and maps removed).
Accordingly, it is not represented in this edition of Bloomfield's Wye texts.
The journal, as the facsimiles presented here show, was never simply a verbal
document. Bloomfield carefully interspersed his prose description with a wealth of visual
material, surrounding it on the page and facing it too, so that writing is but one element of a
representation of the tour to which pictures and maps were also fundamental. In this respect
Bloomfield's Wye-book offers a glimpse of the practice, common especially among gentlewomen, of
compiling sketch- and scrap-books that included verse, drawings and letters, reconstituting a
place, an experience or a relationship on paper. It is not, that is to say, the sketchbook of a
professional artist who intended to work his on-the-spot sketches into finished oils at a later
date. Rather, it is a record of the tour produced with an audience in mind – compiled to be
shared after the event with his fellow tourists, to aid them in recreating the tour, and the
companionship the tour offered, in memory. Even the sketches are social: Bloomfield includes
his own designs, in and around his prose, with his copies of original drawings made by Robert
Bransby Cooper and Mary Lloyd Baker and loaned to him after the party's return. They represent
his incorporation in a gentleman- (and woman-)ly tradition of amateur art: Cooper and Lloyd
Baker had received tuition in drawing—mastering perspective, composition and shading—and
Bloomfield's sketches showed them that he in turn had learned from them.
By including maps in his Wye-book, Bloomfield showed he was keen to anchor
the sketches and the prose to places on a route. Like the published guidebooks, which began to
feature maps from the 1790s, he sought to locate the views in a graduated space that, by virtue
of its cartographic representation, he and others could reaccess virtually (moreover, he
included in the prose journal specific timings of arrival and departure from each place
visited: the tour would be relivable in memory because it was calibrated spatially and
temporally on paper). He pasted in small-scale engraved county maps of Gloucestershire and
Monmouthshire, but these offered little local detail. And so he made his own map, a fold-out
sheet he entitled 'Sketch of the River Wye, from Ross to Chepstow'. Delineating the river in a
strip-map, this marked the principal stopping point and views: it was, in effect, a new kind of
sketch map aimed at serving the tourist rather than at giving an overall survey of an estate or
county (it would have been of no use to a land surveyor, a landowner or an army). As such it
reflected a change in mapping conventions produced by a change in the social use (and users) of
maps: in that other area of tourism, the Lake District, Peter Crosthwaite began in 1783 to sell
linear maps of the main lakes to tourists who wanted to follow the shorelines in search of
picturesque views. The lake, like Bloomfield's river, was abstracted from the country that
surrounded it, its banks becoming the object of largescale (three inches to the mile)
cartographic focus. And the map now had for the first time an openly aesthetic, rather than
economic, aim — to record beauty spots rather than landholdings or political boundaries.
Bloomfield's map remained in manuscript, part of the tripartite Wye-book that
never achieved publication. What he did publish. however, the verse Banks of Wye, defines more
directly and forcefully than ever before the new purpose of touring: not the education of taste
in rules of aesthetic judgement (as in Gilpin) but the mental restorative that holiday-escape
into natural beauty offered an urban middle-class otherwise chained to the account-book and the
office.
Wait not, (for reason's sake attend,)
Wait not in chains till times shall mend;
Till the clear voice, grown hoarse and gruff,
Cries, 'Now I'll go, I'm rich enough.'
Youth, and the prime of manhood, seize;
Steal ten days absence, ten days ease;
Bid ledgers from your minds depart;
Let mem'ry's treasures cheer the heart;
And when your children round you grow,
With opening charms and manly brow,
Talk of the Wye as some old dream,
Call it the wild, the wizard stream;
Sink in your broad arm-chair to rest,
And youth shall smile to see you bless'd.
Here the Wye is a consolation of age: taking a longer view than Wordsworth at Tintern,
Bloomfield sees the river, recreated virtually in memory and talk, as reviving, in an otherwise
sedentary figure, a younger and livelier self. It confers a blessed experience of wildness that
is also a token of masculinity: the father, defined by domesticity, is cheered in himself and
admired by his children because recollecting his experiences of 'the wizard stream' conjures
into being the 'manly brow' of his 'prime of manhood'.
Bloomfield is ambivalent about the picturesque. His Wye-book was to feature
engravings after his and his friends' sketches. His prose journal records them sketching at
every castle they visited. At Tintern, however, sketching was not a deep enough response and,
as he concludes his verse tour, he offers only faint praise of Gilpin. Artists may learn from
the Wye, he declares, but by encountering nature's forms and rhythms rather than by applying
artificial criteria and apparatus:
Artists, betimes your powers employ,
And take the pilgrimage of joy;
The eye of genius may behold
A thousand beauties here untold;
Rock, that defies the winter's storm;
Wood, in its most imposing form,
That climbs the mountain, bows below,
Where deep th'unsullied waters flow.
Here Gilpin's eye, transported, scann'd
Views by no tricks of fancy plann'd;
Gray here, upon the stream reclined,
Stored with delight his ardent mind.
Gilpin is 'transported' when he looks at nature unguided by fancy or predetermined ideas.
Bloomfield's role model is, instead, the poet Gray, who absorbs delight by letting his ardent
mind repose on the water, as if in meditation.
How to recline upon the stream was a question for Bloomfield's own
representation of the tour. His poetic endorsement of natural form led to a problem that was
not resolved in the published Banks of Wye, a problem to which the tripartite
Wye-book would have presented a novel solution. The problem concerns his own medium: whether
nature's forms and rhythms are always so neatly harnessable within the polite diction and
conventional rhyming couplets of the tour poem. Had the poem been combined with the colloquial
first-person prose journal and the amateur sketches as it is here, then its obtrusion of
formality upon the reader would have been seen to be only one version of the journey, in
dialogue with more informal responses which, without it, might themselves have seemed too
slight and private for publication. Standing alone, the published poem seemed too mixed,
veering from the colloquial to the stilted, lacking the animation of The Farmer's
Boy because Bloomfield did not speak for the Wye landscape as his own—known as a place
marked on his body and mind by work in its fields. The original verse-manuscript, deleted
passages from which are presented in this edition, shows that Bloomfield recognised this
difficulty and found an original way to overcome it, for it begins more in a comic-heroic than
a polite manner with a prelude about a giant called Scoop, who had fashioned the hills and
dales of the Gloucestershire country in which the Lloyd Bakers lived:
When Time's young curls embower'd his brow
And infant streams began to flow,
Huge giant Scoop with spade in hand,
And all the Island at command,
With puffing breath and monstrous stride
Came thundering on by Severn's side.
Fancy still hears his foot rebound,
When Stinchcombe trembled at the sound.
Here Cambrian mountains caught his eye
Towring to meet the distant sky
Jealous he mark'd them one by one
And dreading much to be sore the work out-done
'Out-done' he cried, 'Tis true I'm warm'
But this bright prospect nerves my arm
I too the mountain pile can rear
Outdone, there shall be just such here.'
Then stript at once to set about it,
(Look at the spot and who can doubt it,)
But, at the moment he was speaking
His limbs were stiff, his back was aching,
For Mendip, and the western shore,
The marks of recent labours bore:
Weary he rested, full of pain,
By Nympsfield, on the upland plain,
And with a gnashing envious smile
There stuck his spade upright the while,
And chang'd his mind.—Then sprewing first,
O'er Severn's Vale a cloud of dust,
Again he pluck'd it from the ground,
The crumbling earth flew wizzing round;
Then dashing sternly to and fro,
He cut a casual hole or two;
In one of which (a sweet one truly)
Some modern pigmies built up Uley
And Owlpen, by the dark wood side,
Which none can find without a guide.
And here, the happy natives stroll
Around their green illshapen Bowl,
A Bowl all zigzagg'd round about
With one large gap to let them out.
With their deliberately clunky rhymes ('truly/Uley'), slangy diction ('wizzed' 'zigzagg'd')
and undignified account of the country's origin as a giant's casual whim of imitating the hill
country of Wales, these opening lines undercut their own pretensions to the heroic. They also
present a compliment to Bloomfield's gentlemanly (and womanly) patrons, in which deference is
pre-empted by humour. That humour is derived from local folklore: Scoop was a Gloucestershire
descendant of the giant of Shropshire legend, Gwendol Wrekin ap Shenkin ap Mynyddmawr, who
intended to flood the town of Shrewsbury by dumping a shovelful of earth into the river Severn.
He was discouraged by a local shoemaker who told him 'It's a very long way to Shrewsbury . . .
look at all these shoes I've worn out walking back from there!' The giant then dropped the
spadeful of earth on the ground next to him, where it became the Wrekin hill.12 It was probably the comic heroism of a fellow shoemaker, and the humorous opposition of Wales and
England, that made the story appeal to Bloomfield: he mentioned the giants sleeping in the
Welsh mountains later in the poem. It was typical of him to assert and mock his own role as
poet creator, and also typical of him to draw on local lore as well as learned books.
As a beginning to a four-book landscape poem, the lines on Giant Scoop are
highly unorthodox, a versification of the tongue-in-cheek humour of Bloomfield's correspondence
with Lloyd Baker. They are playful, revealing
the poet's enjoyment of his own ability to fictionalise, to tell it like it's not—and in this
they reflect the West Country's status as a charming holiday place, an escape from Bloomfield's
London cares and from his branding as a Suffolk labourer poet. Yet for all that, they do
concern themselves with labour, as Bloomfield so often did: funny though they are, they show
the giant working up a sweat digging. Polished, knowing and displaying a flexible deployment of
Samuel Butler's Hudibrastic cocktail of octosyllabic couplets, phrasal verbs and casual
diction, Bloomfield's light verses still suggest, however jokily, that the country depends on
backbreaking toil—a point quietly made later in the poem when the tourists in their
pleasure-boat glide effortlessly past bent-backed gleaners in the fields. Bloomfield's West
Country was not a holiday-land for everyone.
As different from Wordsworth's 'Tintern Abbey' as they are from Gilpin's
Observations, Bloomfield's lines on Scoop reveal a cultivated, accomplished,
well-read poet entertaining his patrons; they also suggest that he was worldly enough to know
that the Cotswolds were not, after all, the Alps and that, therefore, describing them in pious
and solemn terms would only lead to bathos. Nevertheless, getting the tone right was a vexing
matter for him, and as the tour became a more and more distant memory, and the flirtatious
feminine circle receded from his grasp, he worried about whether the opening was appropriate
for a piece intended for public consumption. Revealingly, it was when Mary Lloyd Baker wrote to him during the course of
another West Country tour she was making (of Cheddar Gorge) that, in the light of her intimate
attention, he again became enthusiastic about the lines, writing in reply
[t]he Cheddar Cliffs have taken up a nook in my heart, and imagination scratches a
picture of her own, like an old Hen in a garden.
I had taken a momentary dislike to Old Scoop, but you strengthen my original feeling and
I begin to think that He may be a personage not altogether to be ridiculed. I have
a great mind to keep him alive. (letter 245 of The Letters of Robert
Bloomfield: to Mary Lloyd Baker, 31
October-1 November 1809)
In the end, The Banks of Wye, to its detriment, appeared without Scoop: the
lines fell prey to Bloomfield's anxiety (evident in the more sober main body of the poem) about
his qualifications to write in the style of a leisured gentleman—a position in which the trip
put him for the first time. He internalised the perceived doubts of his patrons, Capel Lofft and Thomas Park, literary gentlemen who edited poetry for magazines, and consulted other friends too: it seems none of these men, arbiters of conventional taste, saw the opening as
serious enough. Effectively, as another letter to Mary reveals, Bloomfield's was too playful a discourse to meet male expectations about
the proper language for topographical poetry:
Since you saw or heard any part of my Journal, and I think I remember how
far I had then proceeded in my amusement, much alteration has taken place in the plan
and divisions &c. As I advanced I began to conceive that it might even eventualy be renderd
fit for publication, and this perswasion set me about a thorough examination and revision. I
concieved that it was, owing to the careless and hasty manner of its early composition, much
too hudibrastic, and containd a vast deal of useless matter which might give way to the
superior graces of nature, or to unbridled fancy. I had finished it, as I thought, according to
this plan, last summer; and I had the joint opinion of my then companions, Inskip, himself a poet, and a man of strong mind, and
my host, Mr. Weston of Shefford, Beds, and as he
has read and thought more than any man I ever found in his station of life, and his age, and is
an enthusiast in poetry, with a memory truly astonishing considering his multifarious reading,
I consider him highly capable of detecting what were blemishes in a harum scarum story like
mine,—We read it for the purpose of criticizing closely, We all doubted the propriety of Giant
Scoop in the outset of the piece, yet all agreed that the ridiculous thought was not without
merit, only perhaps out of place. Previous to this I had shown it to Mr Rogers, author of 'The pleasures of memory', and he,
even then, in its ruder state, said that it would probably be well recieved if published, but
that it was evident that I had not taken the pains with it which might be taken. I then wrote
the whole out again with great emendations, in which state Mr. Lofft gave the opinion which I very barely stated to
you. I took his hints and the others in conjunction, and wrote the whole out
again, still in the mending way with additions and curtailments, and in this new dress,
without the personage above mentioned, Scoop, I submited the piece to the calm, judicious, and
candid Mr Park of Hampstead (He had seen the giant
long ago and said nothing in his praise, which I know how to understand) He was decidedly of
opinion that the thing would do me credit, and at the same time pencil'd his doubts and
remarks. With this encouragement I once more wrote out the whole; gave the brat a name; and
offer'd it to My Bookseller. I know of nothing which can now retard its ultimate appearance
before the world. (letter 256 of The Letters of Robert Bloomfield: to
Mary Lloyd Baker, 16 January 1811)
Being new to the tour-poem and of inferior class to his readers, Bloomfield did not dare to
be facetious and mock the public's cultural expectations of such a book and of the place it
described. Abandoning his hudibrastic lines, he left out the most characteristic and individual
of his poetic voices, submitting to male critics rather than reproduce in public the verse
inspired by his chatty, female correspondents. What was lost in this new excision from
The Banks of Wye, however, was an idiosyncratic response to the West Country that
remade the poetic traditions in which that region had previously been compassed and that
questioned the conventional pieties of the gentlemanly tour. Without this response, and lacking
the prose journal and extensive illustrations intended for the tripartite publication,
The Banks of Wye was a slighter and less original book than first planned.
The abandonment of the tripartite Wye-book and the excision of Old Scoop
revealed that Bloomfield was unable to continue in a direction in which his writing took comic
flight away from his homeground. He was not helped by those arbiters of politeness and
propriety, the reviewers: 'the author's humour is generally very poor; and the language of it
too coarse even for his honesty of style' declared the Eclectic Review, while the Critical Review spoke of 'bathos'
and 'vulgarity' and singled-out offending phrases. In the second edition of the poem of 1813, perhaps in response to the reviewers'
sniffiness about the colloquialisms, Bloomfield revised in favour of more formal, serious and
socially conservative diction: thus he omitted a whimsical passage imagining a war between
earth and gods:
Celestial power with earthly mix'd;
Gods by the arrow's point transfix'd!
(III, 247-48)
He also added initial capitals to 'king' and 'heaven'. Elsewhere he redrafted to clarify
meaning but, in the process, made the verse more Latinate and Thomsonian, as a topographical
poem was expected to be (as a youth Bloomfield had been inspired to write by reading The
Seasons). Thus the lines 'When a dark thunder-storm had spread / Its terrors round the
guilty head' (II, 71-72 in the 1811 text) became, in 1813, 'A summer flood's resistless pow'r /
Raised the grim ruin in an hour! / When that o'erwhelming tempest spread / Its terrors round
the guilty head'. All verbal revisions in the editions published (or prepared for publication)
in Bloomfield's lifetime are recorded as variants in the present edition, the copytext for
which is the 1811 first published version.
The revisions are regrettable because they tend to cloak the innovative,
common speech element of the poem in gentrified respectability. Bloomfield in fact understood
better than did the prissy reviewers for polite journals, as Wordsworth and Byron also did,
that a tour poem – whether the 'Epistle to Sir George Beaumont, Bart' or Don Juan
— demanded informality, since it depended on the convention that it was a letter home from a
traveller. And this was still more the case in view of the fact that Bloomfield was a commoner,
a shoemaker rather than a lord, who aimed to be a man speaking to men (and who, revealingly,
admired Wordsworth's colloquial 'The Idiot Boy'). Unlike Wordsworth (himself scorned by
reviewers for his adherence to common speech) and still more unlike Byron, Bloomfield was
dependent on powerful gentlemen who were his social superiors. He could not ignore polite
disapproval and so he pruned some of his colloquialisms away. The published Banks of
Wye of 1811 and 1813 suffered by this removal, the remaining comic slang seeming
increasingly out of place in a poem that mostly conformed to approved poetic diction.
Despite its often stilted verse, time after time the poem flares into life for
the space of a highly original passage. Bloomfield's sincerity to his own highly unusual
viewpoint —a labouring-class man accompanying gentlefolk on a tour that labourers would never
be able to take by themselves, let alone in such company—led him to see and say things that
escaped most other Wye tourists. There is, for example, a brilliant meditation on the mind's
relationship to place and time. Bloomfield had read and admired Lyrical Ballads:
his Wye poem may eschew the first-person self-analysis of Wordsworth's famous Tintern lines,
but it nevertheless also considers the effects on the reflective mind of recalling a spot of
natural beauty and human history. In climactic verses on ruined Raglan castle, once the last stronghold of the Royalists in
the Civil War, Bloomfield first evokes the triumph of nature over man's achievements, however
violent and heroic they once were:
Majestic Ragland! Harvests wave
Where thund'ring hosts their watch-word gave,
When cavaliers, with downcast eye,
Struck the last flag of loyalty:
Then, left by gallant Worc'ster's band,
To devastation's cruel hand
The beauteous fabric bow'd, fled all
The splendid hours of festival.
No smoke ascends; the busy hum
Is heard no more; no rolling drum,
No high-toned clarion sounds alarms,
No banner wakes the pride of arms;
But ivy, creeping year by year,
Of growth enormous, triumphs here.
Each dark festoon with pride upheaves
Its glossy wilderness of leaves
On sturdy limbs, that, clasping, bow
Broad o'er the turrets' utmost brow,
Encompassing, by strength alone,
In fret-work bars, the sliding stone,
That tells how years and storms prevail,
And spreads its dust upon the gale.
The ivy embraces the stone; as the castle moulders, the plant prospers, until the monuments
of martial valour are encased in a 'wilderness of leaves' and the sounds of human life give way
to the stifling constriction of the creeper. These are sophisticated verses that demonstrate
how much could still be achieved in the Augustan rhyming couplet. Partly this is a matter of
allusion: Milton's serpent Satan is not far behind the snake-like plant that 'with pride
upheaves' itself at the tower's expense. It's also a result of lexical vividness, rhetorical
insistence and syntactical energy creating urgency: Bloomfield pressures his reader to feel
awed and threatened by a nature that, in the figure of the ivy, represents the triumphant and
vampiric power of death, supporting itself on the works of mankind. Yet, encasing the crumbling
masonry, the ivy also configures a natural, growing memorial to a defunct human edifice. This
is a post-Edenic fallen world, where nature is both beautiful (as in the glossiness of the
leaves) and menacing because time, death and—in Miltonic terms—sin are fundamental to its
growth. It is a world, too, in which nature and humanity (here represented by historical
monuments to human deeds and achievements) are at odds.
It is now that Bloomfield ventures a meditation on time, history and nature
that is akin to Wordsworth's and that may represent his response to reading Lyrical
Ballads:
The man who could unmoved survey
What ruin, piecemeal, sweeps away;
Works of the pow'rful and the brave,
All sleeping in the silent grave;
Unmoved reflect, that here were sung
Carols of joy, by beauty's tongue,
Is fit, where'er he deigns to roam,
And hardly fit—to stay at home.
Spent here in peace,—one solemn hour
('Midst legends of the Yellow Tower,
Truth and tradition's mingled stream,
Fear's start, and superstition's dream)
Is pregnant with a thousand joys,
That distance, place, nor time destroys;
That with exhaustless stores supply
Food for reflection till we die.
'[O]ne solemn hour / . . . / Is pregnant with a thousand joys' is verbally close to
Wordsworth's 'One impulse from a vernal wood / May teach you more of man, / Of moral evil and
of good, / Than all the sages can' from 'The Tables Turned', although for Bloomfield it is the
encounter with nature's overwhelming of humanity's works, rather than solely with its beauty,
that makes visiting the spot so endlessly educative. The surprising word here is 'joys': as in
Wordsworth's 'Tintern Abbey' the visitor unexpectedly derives joys from a scene that should,
because it reveals the passing of time, produce melancholy. This is, then, no simplistic
sightseeing event, no mere touristic picturesque, but a complex response that finds, as the
paradoxical one/thousand phrasing suggests, a plenum of emotions and thoughts from a brief
encounter. These emotions and thoughts are joys, despite the evidence of destruction that gives
rise to them, because they fertilise a human activity that turns out to be less vulnerable to
time than castles and towers are—the activity of reflection that vivifies the mind and restores
the past in memory and that, though it may die with us, survives, in the form of 'legends' and
tradition, as the stories, songs and poems that we make and that others repeat after us. And
these, implicitly, renew the 'carols of joy' that long-dead denizens of the castle once sang
with 'beauty's tongue'. This, of course, is an implicit poetic; Bloomfield was adding another
turn to the traditions, legends and songs that allow us to redeem from oblivion the works of
the past—and redeem ourselves as consciousnesses destined for oblivion. Carolling joyfully in
the poem, he retrieves the songs of yore from the ivy's clutches. As a response to a Wye-tour
this is as profound, but not as self-foregrounding, as Wordsworth's in his 'Lines Composed a
few Miles above Tintern Abbey' to which it compares in its intimation of the ability of the
human mind to overcome time's depredations when that mind, fertilised by an encounter with a
temporally-shaped landscape, is prompted to reflect upon itself and assert its power of
song.
Profound though it is, Bloomfield's response to Raglan remains isolated, lost in a poem of occasional
brilliance that was published without its more original lines and without the prose journal and
sketches that should have accompanied it. Bloomfield missed a chance, owing to his booksellers'
reluctance and his own inhibiting consciousness of what was proper for a labourer-visitor
writing at the touring-gentry's behest. As a result it was easy to neglect the merits of his
Wye: literary criticism, although idealising a fellow nature-poet's imaginative response to the
Wye valley, damned the poem with faint praise. In the twentieth century, Bloomfield's
reputation dwindled to nothing. His multimedia Wye texts, now published for the first time,
show us both that this eclipse was not of his own making and that Wordsworth's egotistical
sublime was not the only way to bring into being a new and distinctive response to landscape.
The Wye, in Bloomfield's verse, prose and pictures, produced an original, humane and at times
profound contribution to the visual and literary culture of the early nineteenth century.
Tim Fulford
Builth Wells
April 2010
Notes
[2] John Dyer, The
Fleece: a Poem in Four Books (London, 1757). Dyer's Siluria is discussed in John Goodridge, Rural Life in Eighteenth-Century English Poetry (Cambridge, 1995). BACK
[3] An example being the aquatints drawn by Edward Dayes and engraved and published by Francis Jukes for the series Views on the River Wye (1799). BACK
[4] Quoted in Ivor Waters, The Unfortunate Valentine Morris (Chepstow, 1964), p. 16. BACK
[5] Thomas Gray, Letter
from Thomas Gray to Dr. Wharton, May 24, 1771, The Poems of Mr. Gray, To Which are Prefixed Memoirs of his Life and Writings, ed. William Mason (York, 1775), pp. 223-34. BACK
[6] Charles Heath, The Excursion Down the Wye, from Ross to Monmouth (Monmouth, 1796), Preface. BACK
[7] A. Cooper, 'Journal of a Tour
Down the Wye 1786', Yale Center for British Art MSS p. 6; Henry Skrine, Two Successive Tours throughout the Whole of Wales, with several of the adjacent English Counties
(London, 1798), p. 9. BACK
[8] Louis Simond, Journal of a Tour and Residence in Great Britain, during the Years 1810 and 1811 by a French Traveller: with Remarks of the Country, its Arts, Literature and Politics, and on the Manners and Customs of its Inhabitants. (Edinburgh, 1815), pp. 208-09. BACK
[9] Charles Heath, 'Useful Information to
Travellers', Historical and Descriptive Accounts of the Ancient and Present State of Tintern AAbbey (Monmouth, 1803), n.p. BACK
[10] Suzanne Matheson, Enchanting Ruin: Tintern Abbey and Romantic Tourism in Wales', http://www.lib.umich.edu/enchanting-ruin-tintern-abbey-romantic-tourism-wales/wye.html
Accessed 10/04/10 BACK
[11] Tim Burke, 'Colonial Spaces and National Identities in The Banks of Wye: Bloomfield and the Wye after Wordsworth', in Robert Bloomfield: Lyric, Class, and the Romantic Canon, ed. Simon White, John Goodridge and Bridget Keegan (Lewisburg, 2006), pp. 89-112. BACK
[12] The tale appears in C. S. Burne and G. F Jackson, Shropshire Folk-Lore: A Sheaf of Gleanings (London, 1883). BACK
|